Point Lookout Lighthouse was built in 1830 by John Donahoo for $3350. No photographs of the original structure exist, but based on records, the original lighthouse was 1 ½ stories tall and about one third of the size that it is today. The two lower rooms that face the bay form the footprint of the original structure. In 1883, the lighthouse was expanded to two full stories and the light was raised to 41 feet above sea level. In 1927, the lighthouse was expanded toward the Potomac River and divided into a duplex so that two families could live in the lighthouse. The kitchen and dining rooms were added to the first floor; on the second floor, directly above the kitchen and dining rooms, the bathroom, two bedrooms (facing the Potomac River) were added.
Keepers of the Light
The first keeper, James Davis, lit the light on September 20, 1830. Unfortunately, keeper Davis died on December 3, 1830, and his daughter Ann took over his duties until 1847. In 1853, Richard Edwards was installed as the keeper, but he too soon died. His daughter Martha assumed the duties until 1855, when she turned the light over to her sister, Pamelia. Pamelia served until 1869, the records indicate that she was removed with no reason given for the removal. Keeper positions were highly political and sometimes subject to the whims of an administration. Most of the records from Pamelia’s term in office were destroyed in the great Commerce fire of 1921. William Moody served two terms from 1869-1871 and 1908-1912. William Yeatman served the longest term 1871 until his death in 1908. His son William served from 1931 as assistant keeper under George Willis, until they both retired on disability in 1939. Robert Fulcher replaced George Willis and served until he suffered a stroke in 1942 and retired on disability in 1943. Herman Metivier served as assistant keeper from 1939-1943 and then as the keeper from 1943-1954. George Gatton served from 1957 until October 31, 1965. The skeletal buoy-like structure off the point was built in late 1965 and was used in conjunction with the lighthouse until January 11, 1966, when Raymond Hartzel darkened the lighthouse for the final time.
